Thursday, March 13, 2014

A Drink of Water


Here’s a curious tale from the Army of the Potomac. For me, it began three years ago, back when I discovered an unusual little document nestled away in the Delaware Public Archives. It told the tale of a Civil War romance, yet it had no proper nouns at all. At first, it seemed as if I might never know who it involved, but after some sleuthing, I put the story together. I found the names of the characters, I uncovered some context, and most importantly, I found some meaning in this document.


This tale is all about the consequences that resulted when a Union soldier drank some water.

On July 2, 1863, the Union 6th Corps trudged through Westminster, Maryland, on its way to join the Army of the Potomac near Gettysburg. It was a hot day, but some of the soldiers managed to enjoy themselves because pretty girls lined the streets of the city. The ladies were busy handing out water, not unlike spectators at a marathon. For many of the sweaty soldiers, it was the first time they had seen a friendly female face since 1861.

One of those handing out water that day was twenty-six-year-old Mary Elizabeth “Lizzie” Shriver, the eldest daughter of Francis Shriver, the former mayor of Westminster. (For those interested, Francis Shriver later earned fame for having grabbed a gun and fought at the Battle of Westminster alongside the 1st Delaware Cavalry on June 29, 1863. He became known as the “John Burns” of Westminster. I’m sure my GNMP friends will like that one.) Lizzie Shriver handed a cup of water to a soldier in the 6th Maine, Sergeant William Sheahen. It’s not clear what happened, exactly, but it seems that Sheahen paused to talk to her. The two youngsters hit it off and before Sheahen fell back in line, the young bluecoat had her address. As he marched off, he promised to write to her.

For the next four months, William and Lizzie wrote letters as if they were sweethearts. Sadly, the war ended their budding romance. On November 7, 1863, the 6th Maine led an attack against the Confederate-held position at Rappahannock Station. At the end of the battle, the 6th Maine counted thirty-eight dead, among them, Sergeant Sheahen.

What happened next is not clear either. It seems that Lizzie’s letters—the ones that William carried in his knapsack—got sent to his younger brother, John Parris Sheahen, who was then serving in Company K, 1st Maine Cavalry. When the letters arrived, John Sheahen discovered that his brother had been writing to a girl, apparently keeping her existence a secret. John decided to write to her to let her know that William had been killed. Then, in February 1864, while his regiment was encamped at Warrenton, John Sheahen took leave to visit Lizzie Shriver at Westminster, presumably to console her. While there, he and Lizzie fell in love, and when he returned to his regimental encampment, he wrote to his parents to inform them he was now engaged to “that girl I told you about.” However, John vowed not to marry her until he had finished school, which meant waiting at least four years. Of course, this required the war to end that year, and as events transpired, the war refused to cooperate.

In March 1864, John P. Sheahen received a commission to the rank of first lieutenant, Company E, 31st Maine. He joined his new regiment and fought with it—and with the rest of the Army of the Potomac—throughout the Overland Campaign. On July 30, 1864, Confederate forces captured him at the Battle of the Crater. Sheahen spent the next few months incarcerated at Richland Jail in Columbia, South Carolina. In 1865, with the help of slaves, he and another officer (one from the 145th Pennsylvania) escaped Richland and after a harrowing flight through swamps, they made it to Union lines at Newbern, North Carolina.

Sheahan mustered out of service in July 1865. Immediately, he went to Westminster to marry Lizzie, which he accomplished on August 16, 1865. The newlyweds traveled north, where Sheahan enrolled at Maine Medical College. He graduated in 1867 and then he and Lizzie returned to her home state, where he practiced medicine. Eventually, John Sheahan switched professions, taking up a position that I now hold dear. (That is, he became professor of military history.) John and Lizzie had two sons. They named one of them William in honor of William Sheahen, who had been killed at Rappahannock Station.

Lizzie died in 1892 and her husband laid her to rest in Boston. John Sheahen traveled to Cuba, trying to forget his wife and move on, but apparently, it was no use. He returned to the U.S. in 1894, and he had barely put his feet upon American soil when he himself died.

As I said, years ago, I found an account that described this unusual courtship. It had no author, but I have since presumed that a member of the Shriver family wrote it (probably one of Lizzie’s brothers). It read:

As the years rolled by and he [John P. Sheahen] was engaged in building air castles, suddenly and unexpectedly the hand of death swept away from his hearth stone the handsome devoted companion of his early manhood and mature years. The shock was more than he could bear. Buried there away from his sight he sought in another clime a change of scene. It was all in vain, upon reaching Cuba he found that his heart was breaking and that he found that the end was near. He hurried to return [to the United States] but scarcely an hour had elapsed after reaching Boston when he was no more. Her body was disinterred and with his were brought to Westminster and side by side buried in the same grave in Old Union Cemetery [now Westminster Cemetery]. Recently near them were laid all that was mortal of the old father—the John Burns of Westminster.

I don’t quite know what to say about this tale. It’s complex, to be sure. But, I find it interesting that some twenty-seven years of marriage, life, love, and loss all came about because a friendly girl gave a tired Union soldier a drink of water. It’s amazing to think that something so intricate can come from something so simple.


(Here is Lt. John Parris Sheahen, 31st Maine. Probably, this photograph was taken in the spring of 1864.)

Sunday, March 9, 2014

Stepping into the Square


At 4 P.M., March 8, 1863, at Stafford Court House, Virginia, Lieutenant Colonel William Burr Wooster called out his regiment, the 20th Connecticut Volunteers, without arms, ordering his men to form into a hollow square. Wooster, a New Haven lawyer, had plenty on his mind. In a few weeks, Connecticut expected to hold its election for governor. If the Democratic Party unseated the Republican incumbent, William Buckingham, Wooster might lose his chance at receiving a promotion to colonel. As regulations prescribed, all officers’ commissions from second lieutenant to colonel had to come from the governor’s office at Hartford. Thus, if a Democrat won the election, Wooster—who was a Republican—might find his path to promotion blocked.

To further complicate the picture, Connecticut's Democrats had nominated a Copperhead, Thomas Seymour, as the party's frontrunner. As a matter of policy, Seymour disliked Emancipation and hated the fact that the U.S. Army enforced it. If he won the election, Seymour might respond by promoting Democrats over the heads of the Republicans, thus using his office to alter U.S. military policy.

A solution to Wooster’s problem came from the mind of Captain Oliver R. Post of Company C. Prior to the war, Captain Post had worked as a type-setter for the Hartford Press, a Republican newspaper. Eager to chastise Connecticut's Democrats, Post drafted a set of resolutions that condemned Seymour’s candidacy as a treasonous act. After crafting this overtly political document, Post took it to Wooster and suggested that he submit these resolutions to his men. If they passed unanimously, Post promised to send them home to be reprinted in the columns of the Hartford Press and various other Republican papers. That way, the voters of Connecticut could learn a cold, hard fact: the soldiers wanted the voters to re-elect Buckingham. Not a single vote should be cast for Seymour. (At the time, Connecticut’s constitution disallowed absentee voting. The soldiers of the 20th Connecticut—and all Connecticut regiments for that matter—could not vote for themselves, not if they encamped outside of the state.)

When Lieutenant Colonel Wooster formed his men into the square, he stepped forward and read the resolutions aloud. He reminded his soldiers that if the people of Connecticut voted for Seymour, their regiment would suffer, for Seymour would surely replace all of the experienced officers with Democratic placeholders. As one soldier described it, “We were told by the Lieut. Colonel . . . that if the Democrats should elect Seymour, and if any vacancies should occur in our regiment, officers would be sent from Connecticut to fill their places!—that no matter how fit a man might be, or how well or how bravely he had won his promotion, he would be crowded out, and that men who had never seen danger or shared the penalty and hardship of a soldier’s life, would be put in.”

Captain Post followed by delivering a short, political speech. After this, Lieutenant Colonel Wooster invited any soldier who objected to the resolutions to step into the square and let his protests be heard. Naturally, this move angered the 20th Connecticut's Democratic soldiers. One of them wrote:

Lieut. Col. Wooster then said he wanted his address to be sent home, endorsed by every member of the regiment. And the way he had us vote was this: We were formed into a military square. Col. Wooster said, any one who is opposed to the address, will step into the square! There were plenty of such present; but who do you suppose was fool enough ‘to step out’ there? What should we have gained by doing so? I will tell you. We should have gained the ill-will of our officers—and soldiers know the suffering that they must endure when they displease their officers. So we thought it best for us to keep still, and let them have it all their own way. But I can safely say that if the address had been voted upon, by secret ballot, by the entire regiment, it would never have been sent to Connecticut.

Another soldier claimed that Wooster even indulged in threats to get his men to endorse the resolutions. He declared, “The Colonel prefaced with a few remarks, in which he desired all who were opposed to their adoption to step four paces to the front, that they might at the next action be placed in the front ranks, AND OTHERWISE BE PUNISHED IF THEY SURVIVED.  With this understanding none marched to the front, and some fifteen or twenty of the regiment voted for the resolutions, and thereupon they were declared unanimously adopted.”

The resolutions of the 20th Connecticut went home to the newspapers and they claimed that the soldiers had endorsed them without a dissenting voice. That assertion was true, but it stretched the truth. Some men from the 20th later claimed that they had disapproved of the anti-Seymour resolutions, but kept silent to avoid punishment. After the anti-Seymour resolutions appeared in print, one Democratic soldier from the 20th Connecticut wrote, “I would like to be at home at the April election. T. H. Seymour would, at least, get one more vote[.] . . . If he is elected the air will resound with the cheers of the soldiers.” Another soldier from the 20th wrote similarly, stating, “Had three cheers been proposed for Thomas H. Seymour, the woods would have rung—for the men ached to spit it out.”

Probably, the Democratic soldiers in the 20th Connecticut overestimated Seymour’s popularity. All evidence suggests that the majority of Connecticut’s soldiers favored Buckingham over the controversial Copperhead. Still, a minority of the 20th Connecticut’s soldiers had their political opinions stamped out by two ambitious Republican officers and the threats they unleashed against them. Wooster and Post invited political debate by allowing the Democrats to step into the square, but they knew that none would dare to do it.

The 20th Connecticut was just one example of a Union regiment that endured internal strife during the gubernatorial elections of 1863. Many other regiments faced similar circumstances. That year, the Army of the Potomac was alive with debate. Sadly, those with power wielded it to drown out dissent.


(In March 1863, Lt. Col. William B. Wooster forced his men to endorse anti-Democratic resolutions. Some soldiers claimed that he threatened those who might not support them.)

Saturday, February 1, 2014

Four Casualties at Pitzer’s Woods, Part 4: Lewis Girichton


As I have explained in previous posts, the 1st U.S. Sharpshooters lost five men killed or mortally wounded at Pitzer’s Woods. For the longest time, I always thought they had lost six men killed. Only recently, I discovered I was in error in my counting. One of those six, Lewis Girichton, was never killed. This mistake was not entirely my fault. Even thirty years after the battle, the Sharpshooters themselves thought that Girichton had died at Gettysburg.

Here’s what happened:

On February 11, 1863, in its effort to meet the August 4, 1862, call for 300,000 drafted men, the State of Michigan drafted Darius Ambrose Babcock, one of sixteen men called up in St. Joseph County. Unwilling to serve in the Union army, Babcock tried to acquire an exemption, claiming that an old head injury disqualified him from service. Unfortunately for him, the examining surgeon found him fit as a fiddle.  Desperate to stay home, Babcock paid for a substitute to go in his place, and thus, a fifteen-year-old immigrant from Bavaria, Lewis Girichton, went into the army instead. Girichton claimed to be eighteen-years-old, passed his examination, and in April, he mustered into Company I, 1st U.S. Sharpshooters. Three months later, on July 2, Girichton found himself involved in the gunfight at Pitzer’s Woods.

Another soldier remembered how Girichton received his wound. This man was Private Jonathan Newcomb, Jr. of Company A, 3rd Maine Volunteer Infantry. You see, when the 1st U.S. Sharpshooters retreated from the initial point of contact with Wilcox’s Brigade, they passed through the skirmish line of the 3rd Maine, a unit sent to support them. In fact, Newcomb remembered seeing Colonel Berdan pass to the rear, as he wrote, “between the skirmishers in front of our regiment, on a white horse, as fast as the horse could go, while the bullets were flying lively.” (When battle approached, Berdan had a reputation for getting to the rear very fast!)

Newcomb remembered Girichton specifically. In fact, they hid behind a tree together. He explained, “There was a sharpshooter right in front of me behind a big tree, and as I was the only one I could see who had no shelter I got behind the same tree with him.” Later on, Newcomb explained where he found this tree. He wrote, “It seems there is to be a monument erected on the most advanced spot held by our troops that day. That spot will be the tree behind which the sharpshooter and I were. It is on the highest part of the ridge that I occupied with the sharpshooter.”

Presumably, this tree no longer exists, but the 3rd Maine’s monument sits in its place.

As the other Union soldiers gave way around them, Newcomb and Girichton had to choose between running and surrendering to the oncoming Confederates. As Newcomb continued, “They were quite near me when I saw them from behind the tree, and I made up my mind it would be death to me to try and run away, so I threw up my hands. Immediately there were a dozen rifles in that line aimed at me, I saw the flash and as quickly went to the ground, and did not receive a scratch. The sharpshooter who had remained behind the tree was wounded in the knee severely.”

Newcomb’s and Girichton’s captors transported them to the rear, and the last that Newcomb ever saw of his green-coated companion was at the field hospital. Presumably, they went to the Samuel Pitzer Farm, the same place where Captain Charles McLean (of the previous post) died. In 1892, Charles Stevens published his unit history of the Sharpshooters—an excellent one I might add—and in it, he claimed that Girichton had been killed at Pitzer’s Woods. Stevens got it wrong. Girichton lived for another thirty-four years. Apparently, the young substitute never returned to his regiment. Instead, he reported for duty with the Invalid Corps, received a discharge and invalid pension, and then moved to San Francisco, where he married and found work as a gymnastics teacher.

It is a mystery to me that the Sharpshooters believed him to be dead. If Girichton joined the Invalid Corps, the regiment would surely have received record of his being alive. The fact that his companions did not know of his survival suggests that the young substitute tried to keep his identity off the grid. Even after Stevens published his book, Girichton did nothing to report the fact that he had survived the Battle of Gettysburg. In so doing, Girichton remained the one body that the Sharpshooters never recovered from their bloody reconnaissance. As we have seen in previous posts, the Sharpshooters did everything humanly possible to recover the bodies of Smith Haight, George Sheldon, and Charles McLean. In their minds, Girichton was the one man they left behind.

(This monument marks the spot where the 3rd Maine fought on the morning of July 2. Private Jonathan Newcomb claimed that a large three stood on this spot, and there, he and Lewis Girichton found shelter from the enemy bullets.)
 
(This map shows the overlapping skirmish lines of the 1st USSS and the 3rd Maine. I've marked the spot where Girichton received his wound.)
 

Thursday, January 30, 2014

Four Casualties at Pitzer’s Woods, Part 3: Charles McLean


The reconnaissance action at Pitzer’s Woods caused the 1st U.S. Sharpshooters to lose five killed and mortally wounded: Sergeant Abraham Cooper (Co. F), Lieutenant George W. Sheldon (Co. I), Private Smith Haight (Co. D), Private Charles Thatcher (Co. E), and Captain Charles D. McLean (Co. D).

Of these five, the Sharpshooters appeared to feel the loss of Captain McLean most acutely. Near the end of the action, McLean received a wound to his leg, shattering his bone. One of his men, Private Peter Kipp, turned around just in time to see him fall. Calling aloud, Kipp rallied four men—Kipp, Private Edwin Nelson, Lieutenant John Hetherington, and a sergeant named Marks—who grabbed a blanket and improvised a makeshift litter. They placed McLean on it and started to carry him off the field. Soon, Nelson fell wounded, and two other soldiers had to improvise a litter to carry him as well. Without a delay, a fifth man, Private Alexander Ferguson, took Nelson’s place carrying the captain. As Kipp remembered, “[We] had gone but a few steps when the captain told us to leave him and look out for ourselves or all would be shot.” The four Sharpshooters did as McLean bid them, lowering him to the ground, but after retreating a few paces more, Hetherington told Kipp to go back and stay with McLean, even if it meant surrendering to the Confederates.

Kipp turned around and did as ordered. When he reached McLean’s position, he discovered that the Confederate skirmish line had just passed his fallen commander. Dutifully, Kipp surrendered to three Alabamians—three men who had then stopped to see if McLean was alive or dead. At first, the three Confederates wanted to lead Kipp to the rear as their prisoner, but a helpful lieutenant soon arrived, telling Kipp that he could accompany McLean to the rear in an ambulance. Kipp hopped into a wagon loaded with wounded men, and at the field hospital, Kipp and McLean reunited with Private James H. Reed, another Sharpshooter from their company who had been wounded and captured.

Although McLean reached a field hospital (probably the Samuel Pitzer Farm) safely, he did not live much longer. A brigade surgeon amputated McLean’s leg, and according to Kipp—who continued to nurse him at the hospital—the operation went splendidly, for it resulted in little blood loss. However, for all the Confederate surgeons did to save him, McLean died on the operating table. He expired shortly before noon, July 4. The next day, when the 1st U.S. Sharpshooters returned to the scene of the action, they made an especial effort to find McLean. Lieutenant Hetherington, the officer who had ordered Peter Kipp to remain with the captain, found the field hospital. He wrote, “I entered the rebel hospitals as we came to them to look for our Captain, as it was near where he was wounded. Those were anxious moments for me. Just as we halted who should come forward but Kipp—and from him I learned the sad news (must I write it?) that he had his leg amputated and died on the morning of the 4th of July. . . . Kipp was with him part of the time. Reed did not leave him only to get water . . . ; he suffered very little pain.”

In later years, the veterans spoke highly of Captain McLean. When one reads their kind words, it is no wonder that they spent such a herculean effort to try to remove him from the field. Five men risked their lives to carry him to safety. In the process, two of those men became casualties themselves. Edwin Nelson fell wounded and Peter Kipp became a prisoner, albeit briefly. The value of a man might indeed be estimated by the risk of his friends to rescue him in his hour of need.

(This is a painting by the late Tom Lovell, entitled, "Berdan's Sharpshooters -- The Second Day at Gettysburg" (1990). It is meant to depict the reconnaissance action at Pitzer's Woods. It shows the Sharpshooters and the 3rd Maine fighting in overlapping skirmish lines, which is accurate. However, it depicts Wilcox's Alabamians crossing a stream with their wagons in tow. This is inaccurate.  In reality, the 1st USSS made first contact with the Alabamians at a cornfield west of Seminary Ridge. No supply wagons were present. This is the only known artistic depiction of the Pitzer's Woods engagement.)

(Lieutenant John Hetherington wore this cap the day he fought at Pitzer's Woods. You can see it has changed since July 2, 1863, in that the cap has lost its insignia. Hetherington took command of Company D after McLean fell wounded and on July 5, and he sought the remains of his former commander by returning to the scene of the action.)
 
(McLean fell wounded near the middle of the fight at Pitzer's Woods. No one identified the spot where he fell, but veterans later said it occurred near the present-day monument along Berdan Avenue.)

Tuesday, January 28, 2014

Four Casualties at Pitzer’s Woods, Part 2: George W. Sheldon


The fire-fight at Pitzer’s Woods lasted only twenty minutes. Outnumbered, the four companies from the 1st U.S. Sharpshooters fell back, firing in retreat. In the process, they lost First Lieutenant George W. Sheldon. Unlike Smith Haight of Company D, who I featured in the previous post, no one carried off Sheldon’s body. He died almost instantly, and with Wilcox’s Alabamians pursuing vigorously, no one in his company had time to build him a litter.

News of Sheldon’s death distressed a friend of his—Lieutenant Edwin Wilson of Company C. Six Companies from the 1st U.S.S.S. did not participate in the reconnaissance, remaining in reserve along the Emmitsburg Road. When the winded survivors retreated past these six reserve companies, they told Wilson that Sheldon had died. On July 5, after the Army of Northern Virginia had retreated, Wilson asked to lead the burial party sent to scour Pitzer’s Woods for the dead and wounded. Four companies went on this grim task, but for Wilson, it proved to be a personal mission. He wanted to recover his friend’s corpse. It did not take long for Wilson and the burial party to find Sheldon’s badly rotting remains. They remained exactly where he had fallen. The Confederates had raided the corpse, but took no time to bury it. With haste, the Sharpshooters buried Sheldon under an oak tree and erected a head board to mark the spot. That evening, Wilson scratched out a letter to Sheldon’s father.

Head Quarters 1st U.S.S.S.

Battle Field of Gettysburg, Penn

July 5th 1863

Mr. Sheldon,

Sir,

It becomes my painful duty to inform you of the loss of your son Lt. Geo. W. Sheldon. He was killed on Thursday July 2nd in the early part of the first day’s battle. Words fail me to give consolation for the loss of such a noble son. He was a gallant and brave soldier and he died like a brave champion of the cause of liberty. You can have the satisfaction of knowing that you will never have cause to blush for his name as a soldier. We all are called upon to mourn the loss of near and dear friend[s] in this our great struggle for human liberty. I had him buried decently as our circumstances would permit and placed a board at the head of his grave to mark the place where he now lies. Any information you may wish in regard to him you can have by addressing me as many letters as you wish. I haven’t time to write more but will do so if you wish. He was formerly a member of my company untill he was promoted to commissary sergeant. Therefore I have had every opertunity of knowing him well both as a soldier and a companion.

I am sir very

Respectfully Your

Most Obt Servt.

 

Lieut. E. A. Wilson

Co. C, 1st U.S.S.S.

This was not the only time that Wilson wrote about his friend, George W. Sheldon. In June 1886, thirty-three years later, Wilson submitted a letter to the National Tribune. It appeared on June 10. He wrote:

One of the officers . . . killed was an intimate friend of mine, Lieut. Geo. W. Sheldon; a more manly young fellow never wore shoulder-straps, and a promising young officer. For some trifling affair he had been placed under arrest, but was not deprived of his sword. All day of the 1st of July we marched together, and during that day’s march he declared his intention of joining his company (I) and taking part in the fight, which we knew would take place on the morrow. I tried to persuade him to stay behind with the Quartermaster; as he was under arrest he had no business in front. But the more I talked to him the more determined he became. I remember this well. We had halted for a few minutes’ rest, and when the bugle sounded to fall in he rose to his feet and stretched himself to his full height and said to me; “Ed, as you value my friendship, don’t say anything to persuade me to stay out of the battle that is sure to take place tomorrow. I will not shield myself under the flimsy pretext that I am under arrest, and will go into the fight.” He did. And was killed in the beginning of the engagement, and as the spot where he was killed was nearly a mile in advance of the main line of battle, of course our dead fell into the hands of the rebels. He had an entire new suit of clothes on, inside and out. They stripped him of his coat, pants and hat, and also his boots, and left nothing on him but his underclothes, and only by those was he recognized when we went to bury the dead on that part of the field after the battle. As I was with him when he purchased the under clothing, it was the only means by which I recognized him from the other dead on the field. We buried him at the foot of a live oak, just in the edge of the timber. As I had charge of the burial party, I know just where he was buried.

Sheldon’s body did not remain under that live oak. In the autumn of 1863, grave diggers moved his corpse to the National Cemetery. It remains there to this day.

In the previous post, I noted the incredible sacrifice that Smith Haight’s friends made to get his body off the field. No doubt, they would have done the same for Sheldon if they could have managed it. For three days, Sheldon’s friends worried that they had lost their friend’s earthly form forever. I cannot imagine how that anxiety must have eaten at them, nor can I fathom the sense of relief they felt when they finally found him.

(As Companies D, E, F, and I withdrew from the attacking Alabama regiments, George W. Sheldon fell with his death wound.)

(This is Lieutenant Edwin A. Wilson from Company C. On July 5, he helped recover Sheldon's remains.)
 
(George Sheldon's remains now lie in the Soldier's National Cemetery, US Regulars Section, D-23)

Sunday, January 26, 2014

Four Casualties at Pitzer’s Woods, Part 1: Smith Haight


Students of the Battle of Gettysburg are familiar with the reconnaissance action at Pitzer’s Woods. At noon on July 2, 1863, 300 Union soldiers probed the Confederate position. Four companies from Col. Hiram Berdan’s 1st U.S. Sharpshooters—about 100 men—led the way. They formed into skirmish line in the woods near the Warfield and Flaherty farms and then pushed northward, moving along the crest of Seminary Ridge. When the four companies reached a position northwest of the Staub Farm, they made contact with three regiments from Brig. Gen. Cadmus Wilcox’s brigade, the 8th, 10th, and 11th Alabama. A twenty-minute fire-fight developed. After it was all over, the 1st U.S. Sharpshooters counted their losses. They had subtracted nineteen officers and men. Of this number, five had been killed in action.

The first Sharpshooter to fall was probably Private Smith Haight, a twenty-two-year-old farmer from New Berlin, New York. When Haight went down with his mortal wound, two comrades in Company D fashioned a makeshift stretcher for him, loaded him onto it, and carried him to the rear. Haight said nothing after receiving his wound and he died shortly after his litter-bearers reached the rear of the 3rd Corps. One of those who carried him off the field was Private Cyrus J. Hardaway. On July 5, Hardaway wrote to his mother. He said:

Dear Mother,

I have been through one more terrible battle and thank God I am still safe and sound. But not so with the rest of my companions. Smith Haight is dead and Edwin Nelson is I am afraid mortally wounded. . . . We brought Haight and Nelson off from the field more than a mile. Smith died before we got him to the hospital. We gave him a verry deacent burial and have a chaplain to read the burial service. That is a great deal better than I have seen done by thousands of other[s] for the last two days.

Smith Haight’s body did not remain buried on the field for long. Sometime in the autumn, his family arrived at Gettysburg to recover his remains. They now lie in a small cemetery in Haight’s hometown, New Berlin.

The trek from Pitzer’s woods to the Peach Orchard is no small distance, nor is it especially flat. (Back when I ran cross country for Gettysburg College, I ran the paved roads between Pitzer’s Woods and Sherfy’s Farm more times than I can count, so I know of what I speak.) I cannot imagine carrying a dying man over this terrain (and through farm fields no less) for such an incredible distance with an enemy hot on my heels.

If it was within their power, the men of Berdan’s 1st U.S. Sharpshooters made certain to leave no man behind—not even a corpse.
 
(This maps offers a rough depiction of Berdan's July 2 reconnaissance action, set against the modern-day roads of Gettysburg National Military Park. At the lower right, you can see the position of the six reserve companies from the 1st U.S. Sharpshooters. Their skirmish line extended up the Emmitsburg Road. At the top of the map, you can see Wilcox's Alabama regiments, and at the far left, you can see the 3rd Maine, which supported Berdan's Sharpshooters, losing 48 men in the process. The four companies from the 1st U.S.S.S--D, E, F, and I--are labeled near the top of the map. I've also outlined the approximate route taken by the men who carried Smith Haight to safety. The primary accounts suggest that they carried him more than a mile.)

(This image depicts Edwin Nelson, Company D, 1st U.S.S.S. Like Smith Haight, Nelson received a wound during the noon reconnaissance. The Sharpshooters carried him off the field too, probably along the same route taken by the men who bore Haight.)

Wednesday, January 15, 2014

The Price of Freedom


On July 2, 1863, the 2nd New Hampshire Volunteer Infantry was overrun by Confederate forces at the Joseph Sherfy Peach Orchard. The unfortunate New Hampshire regiment lost 190 of its 354 officers and men. One bullet felled Second Lieutenant Edmund Dascomb, a twenty-five-year-old student from Tufts College. Dascomb had enlisted back in 1861--the war’s early days--leaving amid his sophomore year. Dascomb fought at his regiment's first two engagements, Bull Run and Williamsburg. At the latter action, he suffered wounds that forced him into convalescence. After recovery, he rejoined his unit and accompanied it during its three-month furlough in New Hampshire, where the members of the regiment expected to vote in the March 1863 state election. Being a political activist, Dascomb campaigned for the Republican gubernatorial candidate, delivering a speech in Manchester that “carried the audience by storm,” or so remembered the regimental historian.

(2nd Lt. Edmund Dascomb, Co. G, 2nd N. H. Vols., shown here as private.)


Dascomb’s recovery from his Williamsburg wound gave him a chance to reflect on the grim sacrifice necessary to win the war. On October 16, 1862, he penned a short poem entitled, “The Price of Freedom.” (Dascomb kept a booklet by his side that contained a collection of original poems.) The first stanza of “The Price of Freedom” depicted a horrible battlefield, one littered with groaning and dying men:

Lo, look on yonder battlefield, where mangled thousands lie,

A hundred forms of ghastly death, beneath a lurid sky—

And not alone the nerveless dead, but curse and groan and prayer,

Arise from wretches mad with pain, devoid of pitying care.

(A battlefield in aftermath.)


Dascomb’s poem presaged his own plight. Nine months after he wrote about the sights of this unnamed grisly carnage, he fell wounded himself, becoming another victim of the war's savage butchery. His regiment retreated, leaving him alone, piled among the “nerveless dead.” On July 5, three days after Dascomb received his Gettysburg wound, the survivors of the 2nd New Hampshire returned to the Peach Orchard, recovering him and any others who held on to life. Dutifully, the soldiers of the 2nd New Hampshire removed him to a field hospital, but he lasted only another eight days, succumbing to his wounds on July 13. His comrades buried him on the field, and later that autumn, grave diggers interred his body in the Soldiers’ National Cemetery. To this day, his earthly remains lie under Grave 11, Section A, in the New Hampshire Plot. According to reports, his last words were: “I enjoy the sweet consciousness of always having striven to do my duty.”

(Dascomb's grave, GNMP, N. H. Plot, Section A, No. 11.)


News of Dascomb’s death shocked his friends. His professors at Tufts held a vigil for him. One friend later drafted a postmortem resolution that declared, “Dascomb was a young man of great promise, and his death is a severe loss to the community and the country. . . .  God shall grant that the fall of our lamented friend may be overruled to the furtherance of the glorious cause in which he bled and died; and hasten the day when the Stars and Stripes shall peacefully wave over our entire National Domain.” Of course, Dacomb knew that his death would cause immense grief, not unlike the deaths of many other boys in blue. There is no evidence that he naively believed that war was some glorious thing. His “Price of Freedom Poem” continued:

Yes, the soldier lives and dies, sometimes unwept; unknown,

For there be some (thank God, tis few) who travel this world alone,

The soldier’s friends in his far off home, how with fear they watch and wait,

When news of a bloody contest comes to learn of their soldier’s fate.

 

But what did it all mean? How did Dascomb consider death? As the title of his poem implies, he understood that Union soldiers had to sacrifice themselves to achieve the nation's greater purpose. That was the price the soldiers had to pay to purchase their country's freedom. Take note of Dascomb’s final stanza. Notice the way he talks about the liberation of slaves and the preservation of the Constitution. He wields subtle language to underscore the essential point: Free government can only come by having free men:

Gods ways are just, this much we know, His purpose we fulfill,

His Children are our Brethren all, deny it though we will,

Our brethren in the right to live, to labor and enjoy,

This Magna Charta of our hopes, none shall ‘ere destroy.

 

For a soldier, I imagine that Hell is a battlefield draped in aftermath. In 1862, Dascomb imagined himself as a victim of that grisly aftermath. In 1863, his vision came true. He paid the ultimate price—the price of freedom. Can bravery be distilled to its essence any more than this?